Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Do you even study mathematics? You sound like a programmer with a passing interest in mathematics, because 99% of math books don't worry about issues like the axiom of choice or constructive math. The only ones that do are logic books.


I quit after a bachelor's in math, so yes, I have studied mathematics, but no, I don't. Still, I'm not just a programmer with a passing interest in math.

Returning to the discussion: adamnemecek said that most mathematicians needed to know about constructive mathematics. When asked why he thought they didn't, he said that most math books he read didn't discuss it (presumably, "it" = "constructivist mathematics"). So I said that adamnemecek couldn't draw that conclusion on that evidence, though I should perhaps have been clearer that, as you said, "99% of math books don't worry about issues like the axiom of choice or constructive math". You're actually agreeing with what I was trying to say - you can't look at an average math book and decide whether the author knows about constructivist math or not, because it's outside the topic of the book. Even if the book does lots of proof by contradiction, that only proves that the author is not writing a constructivist book, not that the author is unaware of constructivism.

I think adamnemecek wants every math book to be explicitly constructivist. That, I think, is a complete misreading on his part of how important constructivist math is.


Ah okay :) I misread you




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2026 batch! Applications are open till May 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: