To be clear, in my original post I'm not making a stance on whether I think CEOs should have made the particular calls they did or not.
If you want my opinion, though, it's easy with the benefit of hindsight to say they shouldn't have. But some industries were, in fact, thrown several years into the future and there wasn't a compelling reason at that time to assume they'd just fall back as things returned to normal. Others should probably have reasonably expected growth to slow down (or reverse) as people could get out in the world again. I don't think there's one broad answer to the market overall.
Frankly, it's a little odd to me that we would expect companies to just be able to weather whatever the economy throws at them with no changes needed. Companies fail. They grow, they then shed headcount. Sometimes its right, sometimes its wrong. But I'm not sure how we could ever live in a society where there could be a complete upheaval to entire industries over a single quarter, and then again 2 years later back in the other direction, and everyone trucks on like nothing happened.
If you want my opinion, though, it's easy with the benefit of hindsight to say they shouldn't have. But some industries were, in fact, thrown several years into the future and there wasn't a compelling reason at that time to assume they'd just fall back as things returned to normal. Others should probably have reasonably expected growth to slow down (or reverse) as people could get out in the world again. I don't think there's one broad answer to the market overall.
Frankly, it's a little odd to me that we would expect companies to just be able to weather whatever the economy throws at them with no changes needed. Companies fail. They grow, they then shed headcount. Sometimes its right, sometimes its wrong. But I'm not sure how we could ever live in a society where there could be a complete upheaval to entire industries over a single quarter, and then again 2 years later back in the other direction, and everyone trucks on like nothing happened.