Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

A responsible 'defense' would have the required surgeon general's warning on the tin. But your quick response here indicates you did not really reflect on what was said.

"defended for their therapeutic use"

Therapeutic means are to address 'ailments'. The ailments in this case are existential and psychological. Projectives are dangerous and require guided initiation. It is highly irresponsible to push these things.

Tarot Cards as self-administered "therapeutic" remedy on HN. We've been banging on the doors on paganism in the West for a few decades now. And here we are.



> A responsible 'defense' would have the required surgeon general's warning on the tin.

I can buy rorsach cards now on Amazon. There's no health warning on those. Maybe there should be but I think we can accept that most people buying them will use them responsibly. It seems very knee jerk to put a warning on every single thing that could be harmful if misused.

> Therapeutic means are to address 'ailments'. The ailments in this case are existential and psychological. Projectives are dangerous and require guided initiation

I understand the meaning of therapy and the types of ailments that can be helped by the use of projectives.

If you buy a set of tarot cards they inevitably come with usage instructions so that you can use them successfully and responsibly.

I'm not sure the danger is as great as you suggest. Have you got data showing the harm of using these cards?

> We've been banging on the doors on paganism in the West for a few decades now. And here we are.

Tarot cards have no basis in paganism, they are the creation of well educated men in the 19th century.

> But your quick response here indicates you did not really reflect on what was said.

This was uncalled for. I read your post and responded to the points you made.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: