Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I'm currently using T-Mobile with an unlocked Galaxy Nexus (GSM version). The only feature that I currently use from T-Mobile is their data connection. For voice calls I'm using Google voice and Skype:

(1) With most of my friends I just use Skype for calls, as I have it running on my phone all the time.

(2) As fallback, my Google voice number has Jingle (Google Talk) forwarding enabled and on my phone there's a client that is able to accept Jingle calls. So I'm also reachable on a traditional phone number.

Disadvantage: Unfortunately both applications considerably decrease battery life.

Advantage: Skype voice quality is much better than regular phone calls. I don't need to use one specific endpoint device (my mobile phone), but can also use my laptop to receive calls. I can travel without having to give my new phone number to all my friends.



This is an awesome setup :) And at $30/month prepaid for 5GB with no contract is pretty nice as well. Only 100 minutes, but who needs minutes when you can do this.


The other disadvantage: E911.

I know that Skype explicitly states that it's not a replacement for a phone and can't be used for emergency calling. What about Google Voice? I would assume that it has the same restrictions.


I remember hearing about switching to voip when the 2nd gen ipod touch was getting popular, and i was intrigued enough to put off any handset upgrades on my tmobile account in order to stay out of contract in case this voip thing took off. In the 3 years since i have barely touched my mobile phone in favor of the ipod touch, but i keep the mobile for 911. i hope a fix for that comes up cuz even at the cheapest cell plan it is still a decent 50 bucks/month that i'd much rather throw at a mobile hotspot or data only plan


If you're in the US, then any phone you have has 911 service no matter whether you're subscribed to a plan or not. You can pop the SIM card out entirely and still call 911.


In the UK I gather any mobile - even without a sim, even locked - can make emergency calls. I may be wrong but I think it's a European law?


I still have the standard Dialer in my application menu that I can use for such cases.


For now, all phones will handle E911 even without a SIM card.

Eventually, when VOIP is the standard, E911 will transition.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2026 batch! Applications are open till July 27.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: