Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Social media communities really ought to observe a "leave no trace" rule with respect to GitHub and other such spaces. This commit from February 2022 is now as of today littered with a bunch of joke comments from being linked from here and previously somewhere else earlier (based on timestamps).


> Social media communities really ought to observe a [...] rule

Oh honey....


Feasibility and wisdom are unrelated.

I just saw an IG post from a collab between a prominently irreverent burger popup in my town, and one of the most progressive wine bars in the city. It had a security guard kicking out a rowdy woman from a bar.

The comments BLEW UP with people who had never had the burgers or been to the bar calling out the "cop culture" and the celebration of authoritarianism in the photo.

It's a joke at this point, how angry people get at things that have the barest tinge of something to be mad about.


/r/SubredditDrama has had this rule in place from the beginning and it's never been effective. It may be a community norm among the regulars, but the lurkers won't care.


You might enjoy reading ann Atlantic article titled something like “I don’t wanna see you smoking pot”. It is an opinion piece about the importance of community norms.


The current title is "I Don’t Want to Smell You Get High":

> I’m glad that draconian anti-marijuana laws have disappeared. But we need a taboo against public consumption.

https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2023/04/weed-smell... by Thomas Chatterton Williams

Some snippets:

> I received a huge amount of pushback for my remark (in addition to quite a lot of agreement), much of it premised on the idea that any social response to public weed smell would inevitably result in the warehousing of Black and brown bodies. In fact, I don’t want the police to put public weed-smokers in jail. I simply think New Yorkers should do a better job of policing themselves: a middle ground in which smokers of any color exercise discretion where the law employs restraint.

> Tolerance is a wonderful value in principle. And as the intolerant have long understood, it is also a value that can be easily exploited. It works best when buttressed by agreed-upon standards and a common investment in informal norms...

> The reflex to dismiss any criticism of violations against communal consideration exemplifies an evolving progressive politics, what the writer Michael Shellenberger has referred to as an ethos of “left-libertarianism.” In ways large and small, it has degraded urban spaces....

> When is the last time you’ve seen someone pounding shots of vodka on the subway? You haven’t, and for good reason. Drug possession was once a crime as well as a taboo. Now that we’ve optimized the admirable goal of ensuring that it isn’t the former, we need a redirect to preserve the latter.


I don't know, it makes the internet a little more interesting. Its not really hurting anyone (in this case)




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: