Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

That looks like a convoluted way to describe dependency injection to me, what am I missing.


You're right, they are related. One difference is simply lineage. Capabilities come out of the erights / security world (e.g. [0]), while dependency injection comes from the XP / agile / Martin Fowler world. More interesting is that to do capabilities correctly you need some type system extensions, namely capture checking. Essentially, this means you delimit where a program can hold a reference to a value derived from a capability. So if you have a function that allocates memory, you can say "there are no references to any allocated memory outside this function call" and hence no use-after-free bugs. It gives a form of resource management that is simpler than Rust's lifetimes. See [1] and [2]. (Technically it's a modal type system versus Rust's substructural type system.) To my mind it's an obvious thing for Zig to add.

Shameless plug. If you're interested in more on this, for a programmer's rather than academic perspective, this is going into my book [3]. I'm writing the chapter of capability passing right now.

Back to writing!

[0]: https://blog.acolyer.org/2016/02/16/capability-myths-demolis...

[1]: https://effekt-lang.org/tour/captures

[2]: https://docs.scala-lang.org/scala3/reference/experimental/cc...

[3]: https://functionalprogrammingstrategies.com/


So it's essentially low level dependency injection where it's not just about the interface but the system and it's resources too, right?

I will take a look at your content, these topics interest me a lot.


That's a reasonable way of looking at it, but capabilities are not restricted to low-level system properties. Here's a terminal UI system built around three main capabilities:

- layout (adding components to the component tree) - event (handling user input events) - react (reacting to changes in reactive values)

https://github.com/creativescala/terminus/tree/main/ui/share...

This is the case study I'm using for the book chapter.


Capability passing and dependency injection are just convoluted ways to describe passing parameters instead of using globals.

Capability passing is just extending that to the level of imports. Your files do not import the global I/O library and then use io.print(). They are passed a I/O library as the parameter {io} which defines a print() function and then call io.print().




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2026 batch! Applications are open till July 27.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: