Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

This is not a slop book producer. I mean it is but mostly for a niche of off grid weirdos like me. We are not writing for the public. It's like fanfic. On off grid forums and discords.

I think if someone wanted to produce a slop book for amazon with 1667 there are easier tools for that.



Here's a question. Tangential I know. "Digression!"

If you had a kid, let's say 6 years old, and they had a "super hero" they wrote stories about.

What would it mean, if you took away their creative process and replaced it with this.

Does that child have a lesser "life-experience?" Or not?

What about you?


But I'm not taking it away. I'm adding to it. I'm also writing my own stories. My post marketed it the wrong way I think. I'm suddenly getting a lot of hate mail in my inbox.

What it really is is a kind of choose your own adventure. You can be 6 years old and write stories and then an hour later play a choose-your-own-adventure game and no one would find that weird


You're getting lots of hate because people assume this will only subtract, that people will use tools like this to replace their creative process. Anyone who does that isn't creative to begin with, and isn't trying to be creative.

Creative people love to play with new tools. Photography was supposed to destroy all art, but it became its own art form. Did synthesizers destroy music? Musicians even figured out how to turn a record player, a device made for nothing but replaying existing music, into a musical instrument. Look up "turntablism." Give an artist anything and they'll start fiddling with it and seeing what it can do, and they'll do that with AI just like they did with electronics and record players and anything else.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ekgpZag6xyQ

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NnRVmiqm84k

The people flooding e-book markets with slop are doing a new variation on the dropship get rich quick scheme, not trying to create books. They don't care what's in there, just that they can game reviews.

I expect artists playing with AI to get into hacking models and model runtimes themselves. It's one reason I think open weight models are so important. They're hackable, remixable, re-trainable.


The next generation is so f*cked. It's going to be far worse than I imagined before.

We are going to have kids who, instead of imagining their own fantasy lands, are given them by AI. Of course the AI will be far superior to a 6 year old- how will they be able to resist the AI drip, when even adults can't.

A generation growing up without imagining. So depressing.

I guess we have a few years before it starts. Or maybe it already has.

Wow.

I hope this doesn't happen. I hope the kids are smarter than us.


The LLM doesn't take away imagination from imaginative people, on the contrary. It's a tool for the creator.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: